The Best Homemade Carrot Cake in Avon Park Florida | Abuela's Cake
The Best Homemade Carrot Cake in Avon Park Florida | Abuela's Cake
The Best Homemade Carrot Cake in Avon Park Florida | Abuela's Cake
A Taste of Puerto Rican Tradition
If you’re in Avon Park and searching for a carrot cake that feels like home (warm, comforting, and full of genuine flavor), you’ve probably heard the locals talk about Abuela’s Cake in Sebring. It’s just a quick, easy drive south on US-27, and trust us, it’s worth every mile.
The Original passed down recipe
Still Baked Exactly the Same Way
Every Abuela’s Carrot Cake starts with the authentic family recipe straight from Juncos Pueblo, Puerto Rico. Hand-grated fresh carrots for perfect moisture and natural sweetness, real butter and brown sugar for that rich taste, warm island spices like cinnamon, toasted walnuts for crunch, and a thick layer whipped cream-cheese frosting piled high.
No box mixes, no shortcuts, no preservatives. 100 % homemade in small, fresh batches under Florida’s Cottage Food Law.
Baking Rounds Happen Biweekly – Order Early!
We bake fresh every other week (Friday–Saturday) because everything is made by hand in limited quantities. That means the cake you pick up is always at its absolute best – never sitting around, never frozen, never rushed.
Why Avon Park Keeps Making the Drive?
Simply because...
The Best Homemade Carrot Cake in Avon Park Florida | Abuela's Cake
Highlands County folks know: nothing around here tastes like this. Whether you pair a slice with strong café negro colao, let helado de vainilla melt all over it, a tall glass of ice-cold milk, or sneak a midnight piece straight from the fridge, this carrot cake turns any day into family time.
Perfect for birthdays, Sunday after Church, or just because you deserve it. Available in 4-inch personal size, carrot cake Carrot Muffins, or Family Size 6 in Carrot Cakes.
Ready to Bring Puerto Rico’s Best-Kept Secret Homemade Carrot Cake to Avon Park?
Reserve my cake for the next pickup weekend in Sebring – slots fill up fast!
Click Book Now to Reserve your Carrot Cake
Abuela’s Cake – Sebring, Florida
Fresh biweekly batches. Pickup only.
The best homemade carrot cake in Avon Park Florida is just one short, sweet drive away.
